General Advice for Efficient Grading
1. Only Grade and Give Feedback on Critical Material
Research shows students can only take in a limited amount of feedback on their work. Give just a few key comments to students and focus them on the learning objectives of the assignment. Make sure the feedback you give is something that students can use to improve for later assignments in your course.
2. Skim Samples of Student Work
Before starting to grade, look over a few randomly chosen examples of student submissions. This will help you understand common errors you’ll see.
3. Grade Question-by-Question
When your assignment can easily be broken into separate pieces (short answers, individual problems, etc.), grade one question for everyone before moving on to the next question. It is easier to remember the answer and your scoring rules for one question at a time than it is to remember the entire assignment’s answers and scoring. (See also moodle set up to grade one question for all students with moodle submissions)
4. Use a Rubric
Rubrics can help you grade efficiently by building a framework to guide your workflow, setting up a structure for your feedback, and can act as pre-written comments for students. In creating a rubric, you shift some of your grading time to before the assignment is due, hopefully reducing overall grading time.
It's generally recommended to develop a rubric before an assignment is due, but rubrics are still excellent tools for helping you grade even if that goal isn't achieved. Rubrics also help promote consistency across multiple graders and provide useful guidance for students as they complete their assignments.
General Guides for Creating and Using Rubrics
Rubrics are helpful to clearly state the criteria you evaluate the performance of in any assignment and give your students an idea about how you will evaluate their work, and what it might look like. Rubrics can be useful for self-assessment, peer-assessment as well as formative and summative assessments.
Rubrics, if used properly, can be a good vehicle to bring transparency and equity into the assessment, because sharing the expected work would especially improve the success of historically marginalized students (Winkelmes, 2016). Becoming transparent about the grading system is helpful for students to understand your expectations of a student work. You are an expert in what is and is not good student work—rubrics are a tool to help you articulate that expertise for your students.
Rubrics are helpful for the following reasons:
Promote clarity, consistency, and fairness in grading.
Help students self-regulate and improve their work before submission.
Provide a structured way for peer assessment to be meaningful and actionable.
Rubrics are tools for describing varying levels of student performance at achieving success on an assignment. They describe for students what differing levels of success look like so that they have clear goals when working on their assignment.
A rubric is generally, but not always, arranged in a grid. Each rubric has three main parts, detailed below and labeled in the image.
Criteria are names for what is being evaluated. These are generally recommended to be performance items (e.g. “arguments supported with evidence,” or “graph clarity”) to measure your learning objectives. It is okay to break the student product into pieces (e.g. “thesis statement,” “experiment procedure”, or “use of subjunctive”) to use your criteria, if your rating descriptions clearly point to learning objectives.
Rating levels give titles to student success ("outstanding," "competent", "developing," etc.). These may also include points assigned for each level to ease grading.
Rating descriptions describes the characteristics of student work at each of the different rating levels for each criterion. It tells a student what properties of their work look like for a given level of success.
References
Winkelmes, M.-A., Bernacki, M., Butler, J., Zochowski, M., Golanics, J., & Weavil, K. H. (2016). A Teaching Intervention that Increases Underserved College Students’ Success. Peer Review, 18(1/2), 31–36
See also Transparency in Learning and Teaching (TILT) resources at this link.
See this handout about rubrics and inclusive teaching at this link.